Greater Pittsburgh Aquarium Society, Inc.
GPASI Home Article Index

 

 

 

 

Getting Started with Planted Aquariums:
Plant Nutrition and Chemistry

Cavan Allen

Finformation, March 2003

 

The last two parts of this series dealt with lighting and carbon dioxide (CO2) supplementation. This month, we'll tackle plant nutrition and water chemistry.

You can keep plants healthy and control algae growth by the same means. As long as lighting and CO2 are present in adequate levels and nutrients are in their proper ranges, plant growth will be strong while algae will barely be present. Simply put, vigorously growing plants equal a tough time for algae.

MACRONUTRIENTS are nutrients that plants use in fairly large quantities. They are calcium, magnesium, nitrogen, phosphorus, sulfur, and potassium.

Calcium and magnesium will usually be present in sufficient quantities in tap water and make up what is known as general hardness (GH). As long as extremes of hardness are avoided, most plants will be fine. If the water is around 4 GH or less, calcium and magnesium may be in short supply, causing deficiencies that may lead to deformed leaves and even a cessation of growth. There are a few plants originating from very soft waters that cannot tolerate excess calcium and magnesium, but most are happy with a GH of up to about 15, so most tap water will be adequate for normal growth. Correction of extreme values by dilution with RO or distilled water or building GH with water reconstitution products is rarely necessary. In nature, the ratio of calcium to magnesium is usually around 4/1 to 3/1. Very occasionally, most or all of a water supply's general hardness will be made up of either calcium or magnesium, leading to a deficiency of one or the other. That's quite rare, but it does happen. If all other tank parameters are proper and stunting and deformed leaves still occur, consult the water company to find out the ratio and correct it if it's out of balance.

Don’t overlook nitrogen and phosphate levels. Nitrate levels should ALWAYS be limited to the range of 5 to 10ppm. Phosphate levels should be around .2-.5ppm. Levels of either that are too low will lead to problems that are just as severe if not worse than levels that are too high. Without enough of one or the other or both, plants become limited by the missing nutrient or nutrients and their health is compromised. Certain types of algae (including beard and staghorn) and cyanobacteria may then gain the upper hand. Too much nitrate and phosphate, and a tank may become an "algae farm" of hair algae. Tanks with lower light and carbon dioxide levels will probably not need supplementation of either nitrate or phosphate. As light and CO2 levels rise, however, plant growth will speed up and necessitate their addition (high levels in the source water may reduce this need or even negate it). The main thing to keep in mind is that the goal is BALANCE, and not trying to restrict nutrients at all costs or going overboard with supplementation. Read that last sentence again. It is without question one of the most important things to learn about keeping successful planted aquariums.

Nitrate can be added very economically as potassium nitrate (kno3) from a hydroponics supply store or as one of the new nitrogen supplements made by makers of aquarium plant products. I've been using Seachem's Flourish Nitrogen, which is a 50/50 combination of nitrate and complexed (and therefore safe to fish) ammonium with good results. Many, if not all plants prefer the ammonium form of nitrogen to nitrate, so that product may give them a slight boost. I do not recommend adding nitrogen as sodium nitrate or urea, the latter being a main component of many fertilizers made for terrestrial plants.

A good source of phosphate is potassium phosphate. Alternatively, you may use a commercial aquarium plant supplement. Nitrate and phosphate additions should definitely not be approached haphazardly! I strongly recommend doing the following. Start by getting quality test kits for both. Test the tank water and the water you will be using for water changes. If supplementation is required, start with very small additions of what is in short supply and gradually increase the amount until the target levels are reached and maintained over time. You will soon get into a regular dosing routine and only have to test occasionally to make sure everything is all right. With experience, you will be able to tell if nitrate and phosphate levels are where they should be based of plant response and what types of algae, if any, appear. Changing light bulbs, removing large amounts of plant matter, and so on might require starting over.

Potassium is next. When plants are growing well, making sure they have enough potassium is very important! It plays a major part in the biological processes of plants. If it's not present in large enough quantities, nothing will grow as healthy and lush as it would otherwise. Adding potassium sulfate (again from a hydroponics supply store) works well and also supplies additional sulfur that the plants need. Like with the other macronutrients, potassium is available as supplements by aquarium product manufacturers. A potassium level of 20 parts per million or so is a good level to shoot for. Finding out potassium levels in your tap water and either dosing potassium sulfate with web-based dosage calculators or going with a manufacturer's recommendation for a commercial supplement are good ways to accomplish that goal. There are few potassium tests available, and those that are are expensive and difficult to use. Save your money for a different kit, since it is pretty hard to overdose potassium and higher than necessary levels are not normally something to worry about. When in doubt as to how much potassium to add, go with more rather than less.

MICRO NUTRIENTS are used in smaller amounts by plants and include iron, boron, manganese, and molybdenum. While plants don't use as many micronutrients as macros, micronutrients are no less important. A variety of commercial supplements like Seachem's Flourish and Tropica's Master Grow are available and work quite well. Some people use hydroponics trace mixes with good results. Note that most manufacturers’ dosage recommendations are conservative and are merely starting points. Tanks that have higher light and more plants will require more.

Iron is used by plants in larger amounts than other trace elements and is available on its own. Adding iron in addition to the regular micronutrient supplements helps because putting in enough trace element additives to get the required iron level (about .1ppm) might lead to too many traces.

I feel a few words about test kits should be helpful. Basically, there are cheap hobbyist-grade kits and more expensive ones that offer greater precision, reliability, and ease of use. For tanks with lower light and CO2 levels, using an inexpensive kit that will give you a "ballpark" estimate of how much of a certain nutrient is present is fine. As I mentioned before, I would definitely not go without better kits (especially nitrate) for aquariums with higher light and CO2. Keeping a close eye on nutrient levels is much more important in such situations. Lamotte makes a great nitrogen kit that lets you compare the test water against water samples of known values. It is not inexpensive, but you get what you pay for.

That doesn't really apply so much to GH and KH kits, though; so most hobbyist-grade test kits are adequate. I use the Aquarium Pharmacuticals kit, and I imagine most others are fine as well.
That's it for now. Stay tuned for the next spine-tingling installment of Getting Started with Planted Aquariums!

 

 

 

 

Up 5

 

 

Back to Top

Questions or Problems? Contact

 
 

Greater Pittsburgh Aquarium Society, Inc.,
founded in 1947
Home ContactsLinksNewslettersExchangeBAPAHAP
Marketplace
SponsorsArticlesCalendarNext Big Event